Mercari vs PayPay Flea Market: 5% vs 10% Fees
Last updated: May 2026
Quick Answer
PayPay Flea Market (Japanese: ペイペイフリマ) has the lowest seller fee at 5% — half of Mercari's 10%. However, its user base is much smaller, so items take longer to sell. Best strategy: list on PayPay Flea Market for higher-value items where the fee savings justify the wait.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Mercari | PayPay Flea Market |
|---|---|---|
| Seller Fee | 10% | 5% |
| Monthly Users | ~23 million | ~5 million |
| Anonymous Shipping | Rakuraku/Yuyu Mercari-bin | Otegaru shipping |
| Payment | Merpay | PayPay |
| AI Pricing Feature | Photo search | AI Price Estimation (rakuraku AI satei) |
| Price Negotiation | Comments | Offer button + comments |
| Yahoo Auctions Link | No | Yes — built-in cross-listing |
| Best For | Fast sales, volume | Higher-value items, fee savings |
The 5% vs 10% Difference in Real Money
| Sale Price | Mercari (10%) | PayPay (5%) | You Save |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 yen | 2,700 yen | 2,850 yen | +150 yen |
| 10,000 yen | 9,000 yen | 9,500 yen | +500 yen |
| 30,000 yen | 27,000 yen | 28,500 yen | +1,500 yen |
| 80,000 yen | 72,000 yen | 76,000 yen | +4,000 yen |
User Base Reality Check
PayPay Flea Market's ~5 million users is roughly 22% of Mercari's 23 million. Your item will get less visibility, and you should expect longer sell times — typically 1-2 weeks compared to 1-3 days on Mercari. For low-value items under 5,000 yen, the extra wait is not worth the fee savings. For high-value items over 20,000 yen, the math starts to favor PayPay.
PayPay Flea Market AI Pricing
PayPay Flea Market has a feature called rakuraku AI satei (Japanese: らくらくAI査定, Easy AI Assessment) that analyzes your item photos and suggests a price based on recent sold listings. Helpful if you are unsure what to charge. Mercari has similar photo search but not the same AI pricing recommendation.
Cross-Listing with Yahoo Auctions
PayPay Flea Market has a built-in feature to simultaneously list your item on Yahoo Auctions. This gives you exposure on both PayPay's ~5M users and Yahoo Auctions' ~18M users at the same time. Mercari does not have this cross-listing capability.
Which Should Foreigners Choose?
Start with Mercari. It is simpler, faster, and better-documented in English. Once you have experience, add PayPay Flea Market for items over 20,000 yen where the fee savings are meaningful.
Ideal setup for serious sellers: list everything on Mercari first. After 1 week with no sale, cross-list to PayPay Flea Market at the same price. Lower the price by 5% every 2 weeks until it sells.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is PayPay Flea Market called in Japanese?
ペイペイフリマ (PayPay Furima). Formerly Yahoo Flea Market. It is separate from Yahoo Auctions.
Can I cross-list between PayPay Flea Market and Yahoo Auctions?
Yes. PayPay Flea Market has a built-in feature to simultaneously list on Yahoo Auctions — one of its main advantages over Mercari.
Does PayPay Flea Market have English support?
No. Like all Japanese flea market apps, it is Japanese-only. Use Google Translate to navigate and communicate with buyers.
Free Tools